In 1985, fifteen-year-old Ben Day killed his mother and two sisters. The only survivor was his younger sister Libby, whose testimony led to Ben’s conviction and a life sentence. Twenty-five years have passed since the tragedy, and all this time Libby has lived on donations from sympathetic American citizens. But there comes a moment when the money runs out, and the girl, used to free living, is forced to think about a normal life and a job. In her search for easy money, she gets involved with the suspicious "Death Club," which consists of fans of mysterious murders and abductions. They are the very ones who force the girl to figure out what actually happened on that fateful night, whether her brother is guilty of what occurred—just as she had always believed.